Welcome to Round 1 of Pyxis Mobile’s Tablet Playoffs. In this three part blog series we will be putting the most talked about tablets up against each other to find out which one holds the most value for enterprise users.
Back when Larry Bird and Magic Johnson dominated the NBA, businesspeople utilized pagers, PDAs and the original Microsoft Windows to stay in touch with contacts and complete various business tasks. But more than just the length of basketball shorts has changed since then. Gone are the days of car phones, rolodexes and Michael Jordan. Efficient business people are still demanding the most advanced and capable enterprise electronics, but now it’s Kobe Bryant against Kevin Garnett and everyone wants a tablet. As competition in the NBA heats up and contenders work out the kinks and pull out secret plays in hopes of taking home the Larry O’Brien Championship Trophy this spring, enterprises are busy equipping their key players with this year’s hot new business tool, the tablet. Tablets are lightweight and portable, and have overwhelmingly been accepted into every level of the enterprise. In fact, 75% of Fortune 500 companies are testing or deploying tablets (ahem, iPads) to their workforce.
Tablets have replaced menus at restaurants, show off PowerPoint presentations in meetings, complete CRM and BI management processes on the sales floor, generate forms and compose emails on-the-go, diagnose patients and mobilize EMR systems, and help consumers find the products they want in stores. Their usefulness has been proven in every industry, and employees are eager to integrate tablets into their daily lives.
At first only one tablet team came to play, Apple’s iPad, a revolutionary device that “changed everything” and has sold more than 19 million units worldwide. The iPad certainly brought the heat in its debut season, but it is no longer hanging out at the courts alone. A few viable competitors have laced up their kicks and are keen on winning enterprise-user market share from Apple. Tablet manufacturers have been hard at work since last year figuring out their game plan, reviewing tapes to avoid making mistakes, and largely trying to learn from Apple’s success. With so many competitors showing up to play, it will be an intense competition for market share this year. Users expect a visually pleasing and technically capable product, equipped with all-star apps and hardware they can count on that will carry them through overtime without needing to be recharged. Any tablet that wants to compete is going to have to pull out all of the stops to win over today’s demanding enterprise users.
In basketball, the best teams boast a combination of brains and brawl. They are athletic and domineering in the paint, but also play smart and run the right plays enabling them to sink baskets and win games. Like the champion basketball team, the victorious tablet will need to be fast, consistent, and effective in order to stay in the game, but they’ll need a lot more than that to take home the championship trophy. They’ll also need sturdy and dependable hardware that can handle a full day’s work, a capable OS that is optimized for tablets and should come equipped with plenty of native apps that can be called on to complete a wide range of business tasks to make your employees the most efficient players in the market.
Let the tablet playoffs begin…

Vote for your favorite tablet on Facebook! (and like our page while you're there!)
Round 1:
iPad vs. Slate
The original iPad defined the tablet industry, setting the bar high with a sleek UI, intuitive layout and abundant app store. In its first month on sale, the iPad sold close to 1 million units. Last year’s champ faces the HP Slate 500 in the first round of the playoffs. The Slate is positioned towards professionals who need to “stay productive in a secure, familiar Windows environment”. The tablet/PC crossover device runs Windows 7, so any application that works on a PC will work on the Slate. Both devices have screens that are worthy of showing presentations and nicely displaying charts, documents and graphics. The iPad has a battery life of 10 hours, which dwarfs the 5 hours of power that the Slate provides. Busy professionals want a tablet that will entertain them during lunch, not one that needs to be hooked up to a power source before powering through an afternoon of meetings. HP’s entrant has a capacitive touch screen that also works with a stylus, a plus for users who want to be able to take notes by hand. But they didn’t include a place to keep the stylus when it’s not in use and the handwriting recognition software is in need of improvement. The Slate surpasses the iPad in video chatting, with front and rear facing cameras where the iPad has none. But even without cameras the iPad will win over app-hungry users with the 75,755 iPad apps available through Apple’s App Store, and buyers on a budget will like that Apple has knocked $100 off the original price since releasing the iPad 2. The iPad walks away with the W in this match up.
PlayBook vs. TouchPad
RIM’s first entry into the tablet game, the BlackBerry PlayBook, sold an impressive 45,000 units on its opening day. The PlayBook, which runs QNX (an OS that RIM bought last year), is targeted towards both consumers and enterprises, but its strengths will be put to best use by the latter. The PlayBook is up against the HP TouchPad in Round 1. The TouchPad, which runs Linux-based webOS, has similar features to the PlayBook and is ready to be used for work or play. Rumor has it the TouchPad will go on sale this summer. Both tablets have tethering-like features that utilize a Bluetooth connection to sync email, contacts and calendar info from corresponding smartphones to their partner tablets (i.e. a BlackBerry to a PlayBook or Palm Pre to a TouchPad). The PlayBook’s version, the BlackBerry Bridge, wipes all emails and other data from the tablet once the connection is broken; a win for your IT department because they won’t be worrying about securing data on yet another device. The TouchPad claims to be enterprise-ready with the ability to work over a VPN and is enabled to run QuickOffice, Google Docs, Dropbox and Box.net. The TouchPad looks like it is going to be a capable tablet and has features which will provide value to many enterprises. But, there are too many unknowns (battery life, price, data contract obligations) and with such a late release date it won’t make it to the game on time. The PlayBook therefore wins by default and moves on to the next round.
Galaxy vs. Streak
Samsung entered the tablet game with the 7 inch Galaxy Tab, which sold over 600,000 units in its first month on sale. Inspired by the iPad 2, Samsung has also announced thinner, 10.1 and 8.9 inch Galaxy Tabs to be released this summer. The Galaxy Tab is up against the Dell Streak, available in 5 and 7 inch screen versions. The launch of the Streak 5 was characterized by misinformation from Dell which created consumer confusion, and while Dell hasn’t disclosed their sales figures, we can imagine that they aren’t very high. The 7 inch Galaxy Tab is targeted towards users who want a “compact communication and entertainment device” and features front and rear facing cameras for video chatting. The Galaxy Tab runs Android’s Honeycomb OS and comes with access to the Android Market app store. Samsung gets extra points for TouchWiz UX, a customized layer on top of Honeycomb which allows you to resize widgets and reskins various applications such as email. The Streak runs Android 2.2 a.k.a. Froyo, an OS optimized for smartphones, which is almost fitting because the 5 inch version fits easily into a pocket and feels more like a big smartphone than a true tablet. According to Engadget’s review, the Streak 7 was only able to run for 3 hours and 26 minutes. It seems like Dell half-heartedly entered the tablet market, releasing a weirdly sized product with an outdated OS. In basketball coaches often tell their players to “be quick but don’t hurry”. Dell hurried. The Galaxy Tab easily moves on to the next round.
iPad 2 vs. Xoom
Apple continued to impress with their next release to the tablet market without mixing it up too much. In its debut weekend, consumers flocked to the Apple Store buying more than one million iPad 2s. The most noticeable adaptations to the hardware are that it slimmed down to 1.33 pounds from 1.5 and they added on rear and front-facing cameras to enable FaceTime video chatting. They also designed an innovative game-ready new uniform called the “smart cover” which wipes away those pesky fingerprints that drive touch screen users crazy, and doubles as a stand when you don’t want to hold it any more. The iPad 2 takes on the Motorola Xoom in the first round of tablet playoffs. The Xoom was the first tablet to be released running Android 3.0 a.k.a. Honeycomb, an operating system designed for tablets. The Xoom’s native browser is a tablet version of Chrome that feels and functions like the desktop version, letting you open as many tabs as your heart desires. The Xoom is almost a great tablet, but awkwardly positioned volume and power controls, and software that one blogger claims feels like it is still in beta give the iPad 2 an advantage. It’s a close game between the Xoom and the iPad 2, and it’s hard to say that enterprises will be disappointed in either. In its first month on sale, 100,000 Xoom devices were sold...impressive, but not as impressive as the one million iPad 2s sold in its first weekend. The iPad 2 moves on to the next round.

Tablet and smartphone proliferation probably has your IT manager’s head spinning. How are they going to be able to support and maintain so many different products? The market is evolving at a rapid pace, and although the iPad has enjoyed it’s time at the top, new tablets and devices are constantly getting introduced. Businesses need to be prepared for a perpetually evolving market by choosing agile solutions that they can count on to be one step ahead. Your employees want the best hardware, and they deserve the best software to go with it. Is it possible for your company to maintain software for all of the leading device types? Yes. Check out our recorded webcast featuring Yankee Group analyst Sheryl Kingstone, "3 Critical Considerations for Embracing Mobile CRM on Smartphones, iPads, and Tablets" to find out how to simplify your mobile initiatives by choosing the right development platform.
Do you agree with our predictions? Vote for your pick on Facebook and let us know what tablet you think should win!
Recent Comments